Tuesday, April 21, 2020

Stamp review: Haganah Organization Centennial (2020-04-21)

Israel Post Memorial Day 2020 Haganah Organization Centennial stamp
יום הזיכרון התש"ף: 100 שנה לארגון ההגנה
Memorial Day 2020: Haganah Organization Centennial

The "Haganah Organization Centennial / Memorial Day 2020" souvenir minisheet was issued by Israel Post on 21 April 2020. It consists of three stamps, each with a face value of ₪4.10, corresponding to the postage rate for an unregistered domestic 50-200g letter. Depicted on each stamp is a scene representing an area in which the Haganah was active: the "Security" stamp (right) shows four armed men in uniform on a training exercise in Israel's Jezreel Valley; the "Settlement" stamp (center) shows a group of men erecting a guard tower at Kibbutz Masada; and the "Immigration" stamp (left) shows a ship transporting Jews being moored off the coast of Nahariya. The minisheet was designed by David Ben-Hador, who has been a designer of Israeli stamps since 1980.

The Haganah -- Haganah is Hebrew for "defense" -- was founded in June 1920 as the military wing of Ahdut HaAvoda, the Zionist-socialist labor party, and in 1930 came under the control of the Jewish National Institutions. It was the largest Jewish underground paramilitary organization during the British Mandate period and constituted the basis upon which the Israel Defense Forces was formed after Israel declared independence in 1948. The raison d'etre of the Haganah and its tricky relationship with the British government are summed up in the minisheet's release notes, written by historian Mordecai Naor:
The main objective of the Haganah was to safeguard the life and property of every Jew living in Eretz Israel. Its troops were trained clandestinely, preparing them for the struggles of the day with the Arabs and (at times) the British, as well as for the purpose of serving as a defensive shield for the future Jewish State.1
As the Jewish population in British Mandatory Palestine grew and spread, increasingly frequent and deadly confrontations with various Arab communities made it clear to the Jews that a coordinated and centralized defense force was needed. In particular, Arab attacks on Tel Hai in January and March 1920 and an attack by a Muslim mob against Jews in Jerusalem in April demonstrated that the British could not be counted on to maintain order. As for the British, they at times supported, at times were indifferent to, and at times cracked down on the Haganah's activities.
Israel Post 1990 Hagana 70th Anniversary stamp
בול שבעים לארגון ההגנה
1990 "Hagana 70th Anniversary" stamp
Israel Post issued its first Haganah stamp (shown above) in 1990 and, seemingly out of fairness to the other underground paramilitary groups active around the same time, issued stamps for the Etzel (Irgun) and the Lehi the following year, as well as for the Palmach in 1992. Disagreement between the Haganah, Etzel and Lehi over how to respond to Arab attacks and to British policy deemed hostile to Jewish interests generated tensions that lingered long after Israel gained independence and the three organizations ceased to exist. In some circles, echoes of these tensions continue to be felt to this day.2 Issuing the "Haganah" minisheet with a Memorial Day theme is therefore notable as the first time Israel Post has sought to merge the Haganah's legacy with the broader legacy of Memorial Day.

The images featured in the minisheet's three stamps are colorized adaptations of the following archival photographs:
Zoltan Kluger 1948 Haganah fighters in Jezreel Valley
Haganah fighters in Jezreel Valley, 1948
The "Security" stamp's photo is from the National Photo Collection, file "D6-036.jpg" -- credited to Zoltan Kluger, dated 3 January 1948, and described as "'Hagana' members training in the Jezreel Valley."

The British government's 1939 White Paper, which the Jewish population in Mandatory Palestine saw as a betrayal of commitments articulated in the 1917 Balfour Declaration, accelerated the Haganah's development into a full-fledged de-facto army. By the mid-1940s, the Haganah had all the structural components of a national armed forces, including a clear command hierarchy, specialized training programs for new recruits and officers, and a homegrown weapons manufacture industry. One of the Haganah branches that would go on to play a crucial role in Israel's War of Independence was the Field Corps (Hebrew: חיל השדה), whose assignments included patrols, ambushes, raids, and securing vital transport routes. The Golani and Givati infantry brigades familiar from today's IDF have their origins in Haganah Field Corps units of the same name.
Zoltan Kluger 1937 Kibbutz Masada erecting a guard tower
Erecting a guard tower at Kibbutz Masada, 1937
The "Settlement" stamp's photo is from the National Photo Collection, file "D550-117.jpg" -- credited to Zoltan Kluger, dated 21 March 1937, and described as, "The establishing of the Kibbutzim Shaar Hagolan & Massada in the Jordan Valley. Pioneers putting up a watch tower."

The Arab Revolt of 1936-1939, whose aim was to abolish the British Mandate and establish an Arab state in its stead, effected a profound change both in British policy toward the Mandate's Jewish population and in the strategy adopted by the Jews in pursuit of their own state. While the British came down hard on the Arabs in quashing the revolt, the 1939 White Paper issued by the British government in the revolt's aftermath was largely a capitulation to Arab demands. The Jews, who had some idea of where the revolt was leading, were faced with a choice: respond to Arab aggression by going on the offensive, which would further antagonize an already overburdened British administration, or let the British and Arabs have at it and hope that staying out of the revolt's way would yield them political dividends later. Rather than fight fire with fire, the Haganah was instructed by the Zionist leadership to follow the second approach and exercise self-restraint. With reports of imminent territorial partition intensifying, the Haganah's orders were to direct its resources to laying claim to as much land as possible. Some fifty new settlements were established by the Haganah during the revolt, followed by some ninety more between 1939 and 1947. The British had already declared the establishment of new Jewish settlements illegal, but a holdover law from the Ottoman years stipulating that structures with a roof could not be destroyed without formal legal proceedings spared the settlements demolition. A plan to partition the Palestine Mandate was ultimately adopted by the United Nations in 1947, by which time the Jews were in possession of substantially more land than they would have been were it not for the Haganah's efforts.
Photo of HaUmot HaMeuhadot United Nations arriving in Nahariya Israel from Civitavecchia Italy, 1948-01-01
SS United Nations arrives in Nahariya, 1 January 1948
The "Immigration" stamp's photo is from the "Palyam - Immigration Ships - D" section of the Palmach Archive photo gallery, photo number 10358, received from Tzvika Harari (צביקה הררי) of the Atlit Detention Camp.

Jewish immigration to the Holy Land during the British Mandate period occurred on two contemporaneous levels: legally, i.e. within the parameters set by the British administration, and illegally, i.e. without official documentation and without having obtained prior consent. The socialist-led Zionist establishment was initially opposed to the arrival of Jewish immigrants whose entry was not coordinated in advance, fearing they would disrupt the economy and culture of the local Jewish society and undermine the establishment's authority vis-a-vis Britain. Owing to British restrictions, the number of immigration certificates the Zionist leadership could allocate to Jews seeking resettlement in the Holy Land was limited, and that bred a system of prioritization that some Jewish groups felt was unfairly selective and preferential to the detriment of their communities overseas. The Revisionist movement was one such group. It championed the cause of illegal immigration and organized transport for Jews first through Lebanon and Syria and later via sea. Even as the situation of Jews in Europe deteriorated with Hitler's rise to power in 1933, the mainline Zionist leadership would not waver in its opposition to illegal immigration. The turning point came with the events of 1938's Kristallnacht, at which time the urgency of rescuing Jews could no longer be reconciled with the British restrictions -- especially as no comparable restrictions were ever placed on Arabs migrating to the Mandate. In 1938-1939 the Mossad LeAliyah Bet was formed as a branch of the Haganah and tasked with facilitating the illegal immigration of as many imperiled Jews as possible, not only from Europe but from Arab countries where Jewish communities were also under threat. In Europe, this task involved arranging transport vessels, gathering Jews at designated ports, supplying them with basic necessities for the voyage, and taking measures to minimize the risk of detection by British forces upon approaching Palestine. Ships intercepted by British forces were either fired upon, sent back to sea, or had their passengers deported or interned locally.
HaHagana Street Jerusalem 2020-04-19 Credit: Amir Afsai
HaHagana St. in Jerusalem
Photo: Amir Afsai (19 April 2020)
Bottom line: 3/5 -- Neutral, for two reasons. First, raise your hand if you feel the black-and-white photos above are more compelling than the colorized images featured in the minisheet. As the reader may have guessed, this reviewer's hand is up. Even if color generally adds energy and life to a photograph, the black-and-white photos in this case are pure, direct and timeless in a way that the colored images aren't. And while the clouds' and the surfaces' flow across the stamps is a clever touch, the effect is nonetheless diminished when considering the images in juxtaposition to the original photos. Second, Israel Post's decision to use the occasion of Memorial Day to commemorate a Haganah milestone is a few decades ahead of its time. The Haganah, Etzel and Lehi may have lowered their hatchets seventy years ago, but they still haven't completely buried them. No one denies the role that the Haganah played in ensuring the Jews' survival in their ancestral homeland against staggering odds, but the Haganah cannot claim the same legacy of unity that the IDF can. Now the onus is on Israel Post to demonstrate impartiality: Will it feature the Etzel and the Lehi on future Memorial Day stamps?

No comments:

Post a Comment